Introduction
Scarborough Athletic | Vanarama National League North
September had ended with belief.
October began with expectation.
That alone felt strange.
For years Scarborough Athletic supporters had grown accustomed to hoping. Hoping for a decent season. Hoping for a playoff push. Hoping not to spend the final few months of the campaign staring nervously over their shoulders.
Now, however, something different was happening.
The Seadogs sat proudly at the top of the National League North.
The impossible dream no longer felt impossible.
And that was perhaps the most dangerous development of all.
The Board Approves
October began not with a football match, but with something even rarer.
Good news from the board.
Apparently the powers-that-be were rather pleased with proceedings.
The supporters were happy.
The finances were stable.
The football was successful.
The board informed Mr P that he was doing an excellent job.
A dangerous move.
Managers given encouragement often start getting ideas.
Proof that somebody, somewhere, approves of what is happening.
A Month That Could Define A Season
October’s fixture list was not kind.
Farsley.
Gateshead.
Hereford.
Buxton.
Curzon Ashton.
Tamworth.
Three of those sides sat in or around the playoff places.
Gateshead represented higher-league opposition.
The FA Cup beckoned.
The fixture list looked less like an opportunity and more like an interrogation.
The tavern ordered another round and prepared for impact.
Looks a bit hectic
Scarborough 2–0 Farsley
A Rare Defensive Ceasefire
A wet afternoon greeted Farsley’s visit to the Yorkshire coast.
The football itself was hardly a classic.
Purver gave Scarborough the lead after fine work from Alex Brown.
Lewis Maloney was unusually quiet.
Rutledge looked like a man who had accidentally wandered into the wrong stadium.
Thornton wasn’t much better.
Scarborough dominated territory but not the scoreboard.
The lead remained stubbornly fragile.
And whenever Scarborough hold a one-goal lead, supporters instinctively begin checking escape routes.
Because everyone knows what happens next.
Or rather…
everyone knows what the defence usually does next.
Remarkably, on this occasion, nothing happened.
No panic.
No calamity.
No spontaneous surrender.
For one glorious afternoon, the Defence’s Ongoing War Against Competence appeared to have entered a temporary ceasefire.
The feeling lasted until the 90th minute when Alex Wiles scored to seal a 2-0 victory.
The tavern celebrated cautiously.
Nobody trusted the defence enough to celebrate properly.
A clean sheet. Historians remain divided on how this occurred.
Gateshead 1–2 Scarborough
The Day The Impossible Dream Grew Teeth
This was the match.
The test.
The measuring stick.
The first real opportunity to discover whether Scarborough’s extraordinary start was genuine or merely the product of a favourable fixture list.
National League Gateshead awaited.
Harry Green struck first.
A low Alex Brown cross somehow evaded everybody, including Gateshead goalkeeper Eddie Beach, who appeared to be conducting a separate investigation elsewhere.
One nil.
The impossible dream stirred.
Then Gateshead pressed.
Hard.
The midfield suddenly forgot how passing worked.
The defence suddenly remembered how defending worked.
Football is a strange game.
Wave after wave of pressure arrived.
Scarborough bent.
Scarborough wobbled.
Scarborough somehow refused to break.
Then came the second.
Brown’s harmless-looking cross found Luca Colville after Eddie Beach once again demonstrated a strong commitment to charitable giving.
Two nil.
Surely enough?
Of course not.
This is Scarborough.
Just before half-time, the defence resumed normal service.
The rogue organisation operating independently of club instructions temporarily regained control of proceedings.
Booty headed home.
Two one.
Game on.
The second half was chaos.
A razor-thin offside call saved Scarborough.
The leaking tap of a defence dripped ominously.
Alex Wiles departed injured.
Scarborough looked exhausted.
Scarborough looked stretched.
Scarborough looked vulnerable.
Scarborough won.
And suddenly something extraordinary had happened.
The Seadogs were through to the FA Cup Proper.
The tavern erupted.
The impossible dream had just defeated a club from the division above.
Evidence that miracles occasionally occur outside Yorkshire.
The Cost Of Victory
Football, naturally, demanded payment.
Alex Wiles returned from Gateshead with shin splints and an estimated absence of seven to eight weeks.
Because apparently joy remains taxable.
Football Manager giveth. Football Manager taketh away.
FA Cup First Round Draw
Exeter Are Coming To Town
Then came the draw.
League One Exeter City.
At home.
The tavern fell silent.
Then immediately began calculating ticket sales.
A glamour tie.
A money-spinner.
And perhaps…
just perhaps…
a giant-killing opportunity beneath the East Coast floodlights.
November suddenly looked very interesting indeed.
Well then. This escalated quickly.
Hereford 1–3 Scarborough
Lewis Maloney Solves Another Problem
Hereford were excellent.
There is no point pretending otherwise.
McHale opened the scoring.
Scarborough led.
And then the defence remembered it had contractual obligations to comedy.
Two free headers.
One equaliser.
One goalkeeper left wondering what had just happened.
One tavern collectively reaching for stronger drinks.
The Defence’s Ongoing War Against Competence continued with no sign of peace negotiations.
Hereford sensed blood.
Scarborough needed a hero.
Fortunately they employ Lewis Maloney.
The man who increasingly appears whenever reality becomes inconvenient.
A thunderbolt from twenty-five yards restored the lead.
Jake Charles added a superb third.
Three points secured.
Another chapter added to Maloney folklore.
Lewis Maloney once again refusing to accept normal footballing limitations.
Scarborough 3–0 Buxton
The Statement Victory
Top versus second.
Unbeaten versus unbeaten.
Pressure versus pressure.
The biggest league match of the season so far.
Buxton arrived believing they belonged at the summit.
Scarborough spent ninety minutes proving otherwise.
Colville struck first following a goalkeeping error.
Thirty seconds into the second half, Lewis Maloney doubled the lead.
Because naturally he did.
Buxton pressed.
The defence flirted dangerously with disaster.
The leaking tap dripped once or twice.
But the flood never arrived.
Then Harry Green smashed home in stoppage time.
Three nil.
Top of the table.
Clear daylight.
Perhaps the finest performance of the season.
Mr P was delighted.
The tavern was louder still.
Top versus top. Only one side looked it.
Curzon Ashton 1–5 Scarborough
Has Somebody Checked The Drug Tests?
Football occasionally becomes absurd.
This was one of those afternoons.
Maloney scored.
Weledji scored a rocket.
Rutledge scored.
Then scored again.
Alex Brown joined the fun.
Five nil before half-time.
Five.
Before.
Half-time.
At one stage the football resembled something suspiciously close to competence.
The tavern watched in disbelief.
The Curzon defence watched in confusion.
Scarborough watched in delight.
The ball appeared to develop a cloaking device that only Scarborough players could see.
Non-league?
More like Premier League.
Ish.
Curzon eventually grabbed a consolation.
The defence briefly attempted to resume hostilities.
Ryan Whitley intervened.
A club record winning streak was secured.
The tavern agreed wholeheartedly.
Officially the best run in club history. Completely normal behaviour.
Tamworth 1–3 Scarborough
Everyone Needs A Lie-Down
By now Scarborough supporters had become deeply suspicious of success.
Nothing this enjoyable could possibly continue.
Surely?
Tamworth attempted to help.
Ryan Whitley attempted to help them more.
A goalkeeping error of biblical proportions gifted the hosts an early lead.
Whitley looked like a man who had spent the previous evening celebrating the Curzon victory in the tavern.
Scarborough responded.
Harry Green equalised.
Then, with the clock ticking down and tension rising, Green struck again.
The travelling supporters erupted.
The defence somehow survived.
Then Alex Brown scored from just beyond halfway into an empty net.
Because by this point October had abandoned all pretence of realism.
Three one.
Six wins from six.
A perfect month.
Everyone at Scarborough needed a lie-down.
October finally defeated by exhaustion.
October Player Of The Month
Harry Green
There was only one choice.
Maloney remained magnificent.
But October belonged to Harry Green.
Goals against Gateshead.
Goals against Buxton.
Goals against Tamworth.
Big goals.
Big moments.
Big month.
The emergence is over.
Harry Green has arrived.
Move over Lewis – Scarborough have more than one superstar emerging
The Tavern Grows Quiet
And so October came to an end with Scarborough Athletic sitting proudly at the top of the National League North.
Played fifteen.
Won twelve.
Drawn three.
Still unbeaten.
The numbers were becoming difficult to ignore.
The impossible dream was no longer whispering.
It was starting to shout.
Lewis Maloney’s legend continued to grow.
Harry Green had become a genuine star.
The FA Cup Proper beckoned.
League One opposition were heading to the East Coast.
And somehow, despite all evidence to the contrary, Scarborough Athletic kept winning football matches.
The defence remained a rogue organisation operating independently of club instructions.
The Defence’s Ongoing War Against Competence continued unabated.
The leaking tap still dripped.
Yet somehow the house remained standing.
For now.
The tavern buzzed long into the night.
The drinks flowed.
The stories grew.
And somewhere beneath the floodlights of the Yorkshire coast, supporters dared to ask a question that felt increasingly difficult to dismiss.
What if this isn’t a dream anymore?
November waits.
The next round is already being poured.
Video Chronicle
Prefer to watch rather than read?
The full October Chronicle is available below in video form.